The Tragic Case of Dylan Schumaker: A Detailed Analysis

Dylan Schumaker

Introduction Dylan Schumaker

On March 19, 2013, a harrowing incident shook the small town of Springville, New York. Dylan Schumaker, a 16-year-old teenager, was arrested for the murder of his girlfriend’s young son, Austin. The case gained notoriety due to the horrific nature of the crime and the tender age of both the victim and perpetrator. This article delves into the case, unraveling the sequence of events and examining the aftermath.


  • What happened to Dylan Schumaker? Schumaker was convicted of second-degree murder and sentenced to 25 years to life in prison.
  • How did the community react to the incident? The community was shocked and mourned the loss of Austin. The incident sparked conversations about youth violence.
  • What was the final verdict in Schumaker’s trial? Schumaker was found guilty of second-degree murder.
  • What was Justice M. William Boller’s opinion on the case? Justice Boller called Schumaker a ‘manipulator and deceiver’ and sentenced him to 25 years to life in prison.

A. Background of the Incident

On that ill-fated night, Dylan was babysitting his girlfriend, Ashlee Smith’s two young sons, while she was at work. The night ended with the tragic death of the older son, Austin, who was almost two years old.

B. Brief Introduction to Dylan Schumaker

Dylan Schumaker was an average teenager living in Springville. Little did anyone know that his name would soon be splattered across media outlets, becoming synonymous with a ghastly crime.

 The Night of the Incident

A. March 19, 2013, in Springville, New York

The night started like any other. Ashlee Smith was scheduled to work her shift at a local restaurant, and Dylan was babysitting her two sons.

B. Dylan Schumaker Babysitting Ashlee Smith’s Sons

Dylan had been responsible for watching the children on previous occasions. Nothing seemed out of the ordinary at the beginning of the night.

C. The Discovery of Austin’s Death

As the night progressed, something went terribly wrong. By the time Ashlee returned, her son Austin was unresponsive. He had been brutally beaten and did not survive the injuries.

III. Arrest and Initial Reactions

A. Schumaker’s Arrest

Dylan Schumaker was swiftly arrested and charged with second-degree murder. His tearful pleas were broadcasted across the nation.

B. Immediate Reactions from the Community and the Media

The community was shell-shocked, and the media swarmed the town. The story was featured on national news and true crime shows.

The Trial

A. Overview of the Court Proceedings

The trial was high-profile and closely watched. The courtroom was filled with family members, journalists, and interested parties.

B. Schumaker’s Defense

Schumaker’s defense centered around his age and emotional state. He claimed he did not mean to kill Austin and cried during the verdict.

C. The Prosecution’s Argument

The prosecution painted Schumaker as a cold and calculating individual. They presented evidence of the brutal nature of Austin’s injuries.

D. Eyewitness Testimonies and Evidence

Several witnesses were called, including medical experts who testified about the severe nature of the injuries Austin suffered.

 The Verdict and Sentencing

A. Schumaker’s Emotional Breakdown

When the verdict was read, Dylan broke down in tears, claiming that he loved Austin and didn’t mean to kill him.

B. Justice M. William Boller’s Remarks

Justice M. William Boller sternly labeled Schumaker a ‘manipulator and deceiver’. He highlighted the calculated nature of Schumaker’s actions and his attempts to sway the jury through tears.

C. The Final Sentence

Schumaker was sentenced to 25 years to life in prison for the second-degree murder of Austin.

Reactions and Aftermath

A. Public and Media Reactions to the Verdict

There were mixed reactions, with some feeling justice was served, while others believed Schumaker’s age should have been given more consideration.

B. Statements from the Families Involved

Both families were devastated. Ashlee Smith was left to mourn her son, while Schumaker’s family grappled with the reality of his actions.

C. Impacts on the Springville Community

Springville was deeply impacted by the crime, prompting community discussions about family, youth, and violence.

Analysis and Commentary

A. Critiques of the Legal Process

Critics argued whether the legal process was fair, considering Schumaker’s age.

B. Debates on Youth Crime and Sentencing

The case sparked debates on youth crime, sentencing, and the nature of rehabilitation vs. punishment.

C. Societal Implications

The case served as a grim reminder of the violent potentials within seemingly ‘normal’ environments.


In summary, the tragic case of Dylan Schumaker is a stark reminder of the dark aspects of human nature and the devastating impact it can have on innocent lives. The incident left an indelible mark on the Springville community and sparked important discussions about youth crime, punishment, and societal values. Through analysis and reflection, society must continue to search for answers and strive to protect the most vulnerable among us.

mf doom cause of death Previous post What Was MF DOOM’s Cause of Death?
Jasmine Richardson Now Next post Jasmine Richardson Now: Canada’s Youngest Triple Murder Convict

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *